Engineer Alex knew that Regional Manager Adam would not be pleased with her repo
ID: 445449 • Letter: E
Question
Engineer Alex knew that Regional Manager Adam would not be pleased with her report on poor labour standards at their chemical engineering site in Qatar. Reports clearly indicated that the poor treatment of workers was in violation of best practice in their organisation. Alex perceives Adam to be someone who thinks that their industry is over-regulated. Adam also prides himself as playing a major role in maintaining the public reputation of ACME Engineering Company as a leader in the engineering sector, including employment practices. So when Alex presented her report to Adam, he lost his temper. “I can't believe you'd submit a report like this. Go back to your desk and rework this until it comes out right. I don't want to see any more garbage like this."
Answers to this question with the use of utilitarianism posed in the case study above.
Explanation / Answer
Solution :
Utilitarianism forms the ethical framework for effective moral action . In this framework , the measure of satisfaction is quantified in terms of the utility of the satisfaction and is attempted to be maximized by an individual . The utility is often measured as the happiness , as the satisfaction of preferences , or the preference utilitarianism . The philosophy behind the utility theory is to acheive the greatest good for the greatest number. Utilitarianism has been used as a framework to argue for the value of different actions .
In the case study above , Adam sees a greater good in the use of labours at their Chemical Engineering site in Qatar . Thus when Alex presented her report to Adam highlighting poor labour standards at their chemical engineering , he is naturally displeased with the contents of the report . Adam cannot agree to the fact in the report that indicates poor treatment of workers which is a violation of best practice in their organisation. Adam sees that the labourers have been employed to acheive a greater good and his belief conforms to the utilitarianism principle of acheiving the greatest good for the greatest number.
Related Questions
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.