l AT&T; 10:39 PM ocean.instructure.com Many members of the commModuley are upset
ID: 130120 • Letter: L
Question
l AT&T; 10:39 PM ocean.instructure.com Many members of the commModuley are upset by this teacher's request but some have come out in support of her. The teacher has taught at this school over 10 years, and has a very good record. She has no police record or record of any mental health problems Does the teacher have a right to carry a concealed weapon on campus? Does the school board and the school administration have any right to stop her from doing so? Assume that this case cannot be settled by an appeal to any existing law or school policy. It must be judged purely on moral grounds OCEAN Account Dashboard Case Two: Kantian Ethics Analyze the following case from the ethical perspective of Kantian ethics What questions need to be asked from this perspective? What is the fundamental ethical principle that you will use to judge this case? Finally, what ethical judgment should be made about this case, from the perspective of Kantian ethics? Calendar 21 Inbox Case: Cynthia and Jason Richfield are both lawyers working for a law firm that offers them no time off at their level. Together they have a combined income of over 320,000 per year, They want to start a family by using a surrogate mother to carry their child for them. This will allow them to have a child without requiring Cynthia give up her career. They know a young woman named Barbara who has offered her services for $30,000 plus medical expenses. Help Barbara is physically healthy and has no mental problems. She is 18 years old and has lived on her own since she was 16, when she left her home in a poor area of Kentucky and moved to Los Angeles. She came into contact with the Richfields through an advertisement that they placed in the personals section of a newspaper. A contract has been written by the Richfields, which says that they will buy one of Barbara's egEs for $5000. Barbara will then be inseminated with Jason's sperm through an artificial insemination procedure. She will receive another $5000 if she successfully carries the child to the beginning of the third trimester (a point where miscarriage is unlikely and abortion very difficult). She will receive the final 20,000 on the day she delivers a healthy baby, immediately after she presents it to the Richfields. Barbara must agree in writing that the child will be taken from her the moment she delivers and then placed with the Richfelds so the bonding process can begin with them. She will never be allowed to see the child again without written permission from the Richfelds. Barbara plans to use the money to quit her waitress job and try to get some career training. Is this arrangement ethical? Case Three: Existentialist Ethics Analyze the following case from the ethical perspective of Existentialist ethics What questions need to be asked from this perspective? What is the basic point of view that you will use to approach this case? Finally, what ethical judgment should be made about this case, from the perspective of Existentialist ethicsExplanation / Answer
The Ethical Issues that are Pertinent in the Surrogacy Process
While there are many religious organizations that frown upon the process of surrogacy, this concept is oftentimes the only option for some individuals to start a family. It is for this reason that some highly controversial and key ethical issues be addressed.
Attachment with the Gestational Mother – In a surrogate situation, the gestational mother is the woman who carries the baby to term. This can be a very taxing process both physically and emotionally – and unique in that after the surrogate mother physically carries the baby throughout the pregnancy, she needs to physically and emotionally detach herself from the child once it is born.
Involvement with the Gestational Mother – Because the gestational mother will not likely be the child's primary caretaker, there could be legal questions that arise in terms of what – if any – involvement she will have with the child once born.
Identity of the Child – There are also ethical considerations that are brought to mind in terms of informing the child of his or her surrogate mother, as doing so may have an effect on the child's self-identity.
In addition to the above issues, there is also the factor of surrogate mother compensation. It is typically expected that the intended parents of the child will reimburse the surrogate mother for her medical and other related expenses. This can include a dollar amount for her hospitalization as well as incidentals such as her maternity clothing, meals, and other similar costs that she may be out during her time of pregnancy.
There are also surrogate situations where the individual or couple who are the intended parents will pay a fee to the surrogate mother for carrying their baby. With this in mind, it is thought by some that surrogacy could be thought of as being a luxury that is only available to the wealthy – and in some cases it could even be thought of as pregnancy-for-hire.
Related Questions
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.