Transplantation of Autologous Olfactory Ensheathing Cells in Complete Human Spin

Question

Transplantation of Autologous Olfactory Ensheathing Cells in Complete Human Spinal Cord Injury

1. Research question:

a) What is THE OVERALL research question?

b) Is the research question clearly stated in the introduction of the paper?

c) Why is the author interested in this question (why is this question important?)?

2. Hypotheses:

a) What are the hypotheses? (list all hypotheses proposed)

b) Is the reasoning behind the hypotheses explained? What is the logic behind each hypothesis?

c) Are some alternative hypotheses ignored? If so, explain.

3. Introduction:   

a) Does the introduction provide appropriate background for the study? Why or why not?

b) Is the introduction missing useful information that would have been helpful? If so, explain. For example, did you have to look up any additional information?

c) Is the relevance of the work clear?

4. Methods:

a) Summarize the methods that were used.

b) Were the methods appropriate? {Was this the best way to test the hypotheses? Were there problems with the methodology (if so describe them)?}

5. Analysis:

a) Were there any problems with the data analysis, including use of statistics?

6. Your OWN assessment of the results:

a) List YOUR conclusions from the DATA presented?  

b) Do you feel that the author's conclusions are reasonable and justified? If there are any problems with the author’s conclusions, explain them.

c) Does the author ignore any aspects of the results?

7. Discussion:

a) Did the authors compare their results with previous published papers?

b) Are the implications of the results properly discussed?

c) Are the conclusions clearly stated?

d) In addition to what the authors discussed, what further studies would YOU find interesting to pursue?

8. Abstract (if there is one):

a) Does the Abstract really give an appropriate summary of the paper?

Explanation / Answer

1. (a) The research question is what will be the effect if we transplant autologous olfactory ensheathing cells in human spinal cord.

(b) Yes research topic is shown in the heading .

(C) . Yes it is important as it should be visible and understandable to everyone

Related Questions

Navigate

• Browse (All)
• Browse T
• Subjects

Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.