Written Assignment 1: Trace the Scientific Method in a Primary Scientific Articl
ID: 52538 • Letter: W
Question
Written Assignment 1: Trace the Scientific Method in a Primary Scientific Article
Addresses course outcomes 1 and 4:
recognize and explain how the scientific method is used to solve problems
weigh evidence and make decisions based on strengths and limitations of scientific knowledge and the scientific method
Before starting this assignment you might want to revisit the Scientific Method Tutorial in the Science Learning Center under the Content area.
Researchers recently investigated whether or not coffee prevented the development of high blood sugar (hyperglycemia) in laboratory mice. The mice used in this experiment have a mutation that makes them become diabetic. Read about this research study in this article published on the Science Daily web-site New Evidence That Drinking Coffee May Reduce the Risk of Diabetes as well as the following summary:
A group of 11 mice was given water, and another group of 10 mice was supplied with diluted black coffee (coffee:water 1:1) as drinking fluids for five weeks. The composition of the diets and living conditions were similar for both groups of mice. Blood glucose was monitored weekly for all mice. After five weeks, there was no change in average body weight between groups. Results indicated that blood glucose concentrations increased significantly in the mice that drank water compared with those that were supplied with coffee. Finally, blood glucose concentration in the coffee group exhibited a 30 percent decrease compared with that in the water group. In the original paper, the investigators acknowledged that the coffee for the experiment was supplied as a gift from a corporation.
Then answer the following questions in your own words:
1. Identify and describe the steps of the scientific method. Which observations do you think the scientists made leading up to this research study? Given your understanding of the experimental design, formulate a specific hypothesis that is being tested in this experiment. Describe the experimental design including control and treatment group(s), and dependent and independent variables. Summarize the results and the conclusion (50 points)
2. Criticize the research described. Things to consider: Were the test subjects and treatments relevant and appropriate? Was the sample size large enough? Were the methods used appropriate? Can you think of a potential bias in a research study like this? What are the limitations of the conclusions made in this research study? Address at least two of these questions in your critique of the research study (20 points).
3. Discuss the relevance of this type of research, both for the world in general and for you personally (20 points).
4. Write answers in your own words with proper grammar and spelling (10 points).
5. Your work should be approximately 300 - 400 words, double-spaced. All of your references should be in APA format.
Explanation / Answer
1. The steps of the scientific method were:
a. An objective for the study was chosen. This objective was to test the effect of coffee on prevention of high blood glucose concentration.
b. Previous researches were reviewed to collect data and gather background information on the field.
c. The scientists then developed an hypothesis that coffee affected glucose concentration in the body.
d. The experiment was then carried out by carefully selecting test and control mice. These mice were then observed for physiological changes as the experiment proceeded.
e. After the experiment was done scientists collected all the data and reviewed their findings and concluded that the hypothesis is acceptable and coffee does prevent high glucose levels.
f. These results were then duly published in the journal.
2. The treatment was not completely appropriate as no aspect of the study was relevant to the negative effects that the product might bring. The sample size was very small in comparison to the generally asserted one.
3. A potential bias in a study like this can be some kind of monetary profit as the testing material came from a corporation which may have wanted the experiment to succeed for financial profits only.
Related Questions
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.