1. Susan and her neighbors who live in an older, working-class neighborhood had
ID: 438086 • Letter: 1
Question
1. Susan and her neighbors who live in an older, working-class neighborhood had their homes seized by the city pursuant to eminent domain since the city wants to turn the property over to a big private developer who plans to build a mall, thereby increasing the tax base of the city. Susan and her neighbors have been evicted; but they are promised "fair market value" for their homes. However, they want to stay in their homes. They sue the city for acting in an unconstitutional manner. The likely result of that lawsuit would be:Answer
Susan and her neighbors will win since the city seized their properties merely for a mall and not something major like an airport extension.
Susan and her neighbors will win because the city did not use the properties itself but turned them over to a private developer.
Susan and her neighbors will win since under the old common law, "An Englishman's home is his castle," and thus government cannot constitutionally seize private property.
Susan and her neighbors will lose, assuming they receive fair market value for their properties, since the city acted in a constitutional manner.
Explanation / Answer
1. Susan and her neighbors who live in an older, working-class neighborhood had their homes seized by the city pursuant to eminent domain since the city wants to turn the property over to a big private developer who plans to build a mall, thereby increasing the tax base of the city. Susan and her neighbors have been evicted; but they are promised "fair market value" for their homes. However, they want to stay in their homes. They sue the city for acting in an unconstitutional manner. The likely result of that lawsuit would be:
Answer
Susan and her neighbors will win since the city seized their properties merely for a mall and not something major like an airport extension.
Susan and her neighbors will win because the city did not use the properties itself but turned them over to a private developer.-correct option
Susan and her neighbors will win since under the old common law, "An Englishman's home is his castle," and thus government cannot constitutionally seize private property.
Susan and her neighbors will lose, assuming they receive fair market value for their properties, since the city acted in a constitutional manner.
Related Questions
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.