guess not,\" Crane said-i havent stone any. But you mighe Dr. Wol sakd. \"Tm afr
ID: 3501232 • Letter: G
Question
guess not," Crane said-i havent stone any. But you mighe Dr. Wol sakd. "Tm afraid you Crane smiled That's just the chance the world aly acting to peotect others wile ging wishes of your patient? thing yet might let yourself go and kill someone will have to take isn't it? 3. Should pycholgts and by law to act to protect the tane are not their patients? people wh 4. How does this case compare to the Tarsof 1. Suppose that you are Dr: Wolle To take the lea steps necessary to have Crane committed against his will wsquires that you violate his confidentiality What justification might you offer for doing this? DECISION SCENARIO 8 Gary started to ask about Shawn's family, b Shawn, no offense, man, but do you still see Nurse or Executioner? found he couldn't let it go. Gary had been waiting at Denny's for a good forty- five minutes when Shawn Harrison finally walked in the door. The two men had been housemates in blic yourself as a nurse? I mean, we were trained to people's lives and to 'do no harm, right? It's not health clinic in Houston, before Shawn had been laid like those guys consented to off. It had been over a year since they had met. nursing school and later worked together at a public your 'treatment "I never understood that kind of talk Shaw Sorry, man. I had to work late last night and overslept. Shawn's eyes were bloodshot and he said. "We used to harm patients all the time when we pumped them full of chemo. That hurts for a hell of a lot longer than this does. Besides, if I dont looked thinner than Gary remembered That sucks Gary said. "Are you back in the ER these days?" do this job, somebody else will. Now, what are yo having for breakfast?" 1. Is Shawn still acting as a nurse or has he become Naw. I've been working up at Huntsville." an executioner? Is his response to Gary's questions persuasive? Why or why not? "Yup, it was the only full-time job I could find. They've got me-well, I don't really like to talk about it, but they've got me working on the death unit. Ordering the meds, cutting down veins, insert 2. Under what circumstances, if any, is a medical professional justified in acting against a patient's best medical interests? Why? ing IVs. It can be pretty intense. Whoa. I can imagine-or maybe I can't. " Gary took a sip of his coffee. "But I got to ask, does the 3. What about acting against a person's consent as well as against her best medical interests? Are there any situations in which that might be justified? Describe them. work ever bother you?" "Sometimes it does. Those guys up there did p that tube around their arm. Shawn nodded to the waitress for a cup of coffee. "I some terrible things, but it's still hard to look them in the eye when I strap their arm." 4. Evaluate Shawn's argument that he is reducing s figure, though, they're going to die anyway, and I've seemed like he wanted to change the subject fering by making executions less painful. What ithe made the same argument about helping a torturer extract information more quickly from a detainee? Would the substance of his position be any different got the skills to make it as painless as possible." HeExplanation / Answer
1. shawn is no mare acting as a nurse , he really has become an executioner and accepted the fact . He is persuavisive towards garys questions where he tries to convince gary that what he is doing needs to be done and if he doesnt somebody else will.
2. In no circumstances shall a medical professional work against the best intests of the patient.Now that best intrest may difffer from patient to patient and how they percieve the their best intrests.
3. Well if youtake it as face value there are no instances where working against consent and the best intrest of the patient may be justified , but this is not as simple as that some cases might get really complicated wghere the person does nto consent you to treat them and doesnt want treatment as seeing it too painful to go through in that cadse thugh still morally wrong it might be justifies in similar cases.
4. .Shawn has to justify it not to only his friends and family bur even himself thst even though he kills people for a living he still is the good guy who they knew who joined the nursing industry to help out people.That said if shawn worked for a torturer the same argment will fall apart as veryone wishes for painless death , as a nurse his oath is to do no harm if he makes the executon painless the person even though they die do not suffer,though as a torturer his main motive is to cause harm and the purpose of his argument is defeated.
Related Questions
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.