4.Examine this issue from the perspective of a Kantian ethicist. Assuming govern

Question

4.Examine this issue from the perspective of a Kantian ethicist. Assuming governmental regulation would lead to some degree of restriction of freedom of speech and press freedom but it would also maximize and secure the wellbeing of society. Which of the following statements best reflect a Kantian view on the issue?

a)Restriction of free speech in such situation is acceptable because it would have a beneficial consequence of making society safe and secure.

b)Restriction of free speech in such context is wrong because it would violate people’s autonomy right of self-determination.

c)Restriction of free speech in such context is wrong because it would violate people’s constitutional right to free speech.

d)Restriction of free speech in such situation is acceptable if the majority of the people in the society approve it.  

Explanation / Answer

a) Restriction of free speech in such situation is acceptable because it would have a beneficial consequence of making society safe and secure.

The kantian ethics does not lay emphasis on morality or feelings. Rather, it only lays emphasis on duties. According to this theory, duty comes above all. If the government has decided on restriction of speech, it is our duty to follow the restriction of speech.

Related Questions

Navigate

• Browse (All)
• Browse 4
• Subjects

Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.