.ill AT&T; 10:27 PM ocean.instructure.com OCEAN This is a graded discussion: 100
ID: 130071 • Letter: #
Question
.ill AT&T; 10:27 PM ocean.instructure.com OCEAN This is a graded discussion: 100 points M7. Discussion Account Topic An ethics committee is a forum where different points of view can be debated with an eye to the practical problem of arriving at sound moral judgments. Within the committee, everyone has the right to express his or her point of view and to persuade others using argument. Most points of view have at least some truth to them. By considering a variety of points of view, and evaluating the strengths and weaknesses of each one, our aim is to arrive at the best point of view, the one that has captured the most strength, and overcome the most Courses Calendar Imagine that your class has been formed into a large ethics committee. The goal for this committee is to get a conversation going, where you use the ideas that you are learning about ethics, to help address some real world problems You should be presenting your own views, as well as responding to each others ideas as the discussion develops. Don't be shy about disagreeing with and challenging each other, as well as developing each others ideas Help Case One: Utilitarian Ethics Analyze the following case from the ethical perspective of Utilitarian ethics What questions need to be asked from this perspective? What is the fundamental ethical principle that you will use to judge this case? Finally, what ethical judgment should be made about this case, from the perspective of Utilitarian ethics Case: A high school teacher in California is seeking the right to carry a concealed gun to school. She has a license for the weapon and has over 25 hours of training in its use and in firearm safety. She claims that this is the only serious way to protect the school from an incidence of gun violence. She argues that if every school had a few staff that were armed it would act as a deterrent to violence plus provide each school with an immediate defense in case any incident were to occur. At a minimum, she claims that she has a right to protect herself whille she is on the job. Many members of the commModuley are upset by this teachers request but some have come out in support of her. The teacher has taught at this school over 10 years, and has a very good record. She has no police record or record of any mental health problems Does the teacher have a right to carry a concealed weapon on campus? Does the school board and the school administration have any right to stop her from doing so? Assume that this case cannot be settled by an appeal to any existing law or school policy. It must be judged purely on moral groundsExplanation / Answer
Utilitarianism is a theory that determines right from wrong based on the outcome. Thus it is a moral frame work that determines an action.
According to the above case study, a school teacher is seeking the rights to carry a gun to school has created a frown in many. Despite have a good background and training to use it for safely. Since there is a lot of mass shooting that has been taken place over the few years and months in schools and college campuses, which is a major threat to both the student and teacher. Hence she claims that she has the rights to protect herself and others while in the job.
To the question: Does the teacher have the rights?
Yes, she does have the right to protect herself and others from any direct or indirect threat. Few states in US have already allowed the faculty and others to carry a concealed gun to protect them. Others schools have armed security forces too. In country like Pakistan bills has been passed to allow the teachers and staff to carry arms to school in case of terror attack.
Before the approval of the same, lot of preparation must be taken into consideration interms of safety and training. Since most of the people fear if it goes the wrong hands it might lead to another tragedy.
Yes, the school has the rights to stop her, since it has the power to make decision, school shoul take necessary measures before the approval of the same.
Related Questions
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.