QUESTION 9 [20 marks] a. Define the Ricardian equivalence and briefly discuss wh
ID: 1154734 • Letter: Q
Question
QUESTION 9 [20 marks] a. Define the Ricardian equivalence and briefly discuss whether an increase in fiscal deficit will cause an equal decrease in a country's net exports (i.e. "twin deficits"). [4 marks] b. Suppose that the government in a Ricardian equivalence world/economy consumes only foreign goods, rather than the domestic goods. What effects would a permanent increase in government spending have on an economy's equilibrium real exchange rate? Explain. [6 marks] c. Consider the two-good version in a world in which Ricardian equivalence holds. Suppose that households receive constant flow of workers' remittances from the rest of the world each period. How would a permanent increase in this flow affect: i) the home country's real exchange rate; i) the home country's net exports; lli) the home country's current account balance? [10 marks]Explanation / Answer
a)The Ricardian equivalence is a financial theory holding that shoppers are forward looking thus disguise the administration's spending requirement when settling on their utilization choices. This prompts the outcome that, for a given example of government spending, the technique for financing that spending does not influence specialists' utilization choices, and accordingly, it doesn't change total request. Along these lines, this hypothesis is utilized as a contention against tax reductions and spending builds meant to support total request.
The twin shortages theory or the twin shortfalls marvel, is the recommendation that there is a solid causal connection between a country's administration spending parity and its present record adjust.
Standard macroeconomic hypothesis focuses to how a spending shortfall can be a contributing component to a present record shortage. This connection can be seen from considering the national bookkeeping model of the economy:
Y=C+I+G+(X-M),
where Y speaks to national pay or GDP, C is utilization, I is venture, G is government spending and (X– M) remains for net fares. This speaks to GDP since all the creation in an economy (the left hand side of the condition) is utilized as utilization (C), speculation (I), government spending (G), and merchandise that are sent out in overabundance of imports (NX). Another condition characterizing GDP utilizing elective terms (which in principle brings about a similar esteem) is
Y=C+S+T,
where Y is again GDP, C is utilization, S is sparing, and T is charges. This is on the grounds that national wage is likewise equivalent to yield, and all individual wage either goes to pay for utilization (C), to pay charges (T), or is spared (S).
An economy is esteemed to have a twofold shortfall on the off chance that it has a present record shortage and a monetary deficiency. As a result, the economy is obtaining from nonnatives in return for outside made products. Conventional macroeconomics predicts that tireless twofold shortages will prompt cash degrading/deterioration that can be extreme and sudden.
b)The problem of measuring exogenous fiscal policy and maintaining ceteris paribus assumptions is not unique to studies of the real exchange rate. Indeed, these problems loom large in estimating a government spending multipliers and were central in the recent debates over policy responses during the global financial crisis. For example, the International Monetary Fund, in its 2012 World Economic Outlook , reports that systematically low estimates of fiscal multipliers contributed to unexpectedly sluggish European recovery by encouraging overly aggressive fiscal consolidation among European governments. The particular ceterisparibus failures the IMF cites include a failure to account for synchronized fiscalconsolidation, cross?country economic slack, and the zero bound constraint on monetary policy. More recently, in their critique of standard methods of estimating fiscal multipliers, Nakamura and Steinsson (2014), take an intra?U.S. approach to estimate fiscal multipliers because monetary policy is constant within the United States. They follow other authors (e.g., Hooker and Knetter, 1997) in instrumenting exogenous fiscal shocks using differences in federal military spending at the state level; the identifying assumption being that the United States does not embark on military buildups because states receiving larger shares of military spending are doing systematically worse than other states.
c)The cutting edge adaptation of the Ricardian Model expect that there are two nations, delivering two merchandise, utilizing one factor of generation, typically work. The model is a general harmony display in which all business sectors (i.e., merchandise and factors) are splendidly focused. The merchandise created are thought to be homogeneous crosswise over nations and firms inside an industry. Products can be costlessly dispatched between nations (i.e., there are no transportation costs). Work is homogeneous inside a nation however may have diverse productivities crosswise over nations. This infers the creation innovation is expected to contrast crosswise over nations. Work is costlessly versatile crosswise over businesses inside a nation however is stationary crosswise over nations. Full work of work is likewise expected. Customers (the workers) are accepted to expand utility subject to a pay requirement.
Perfect Competition
Perfect Competition in all business sectors implies that the accompanying conditions are accepted to hold.
Two Countries
The instance of two nations is utilized to streamline the model examination. Give one nation a chance to be the US, the other France *. Note, anything related only to France* in the model will be set apart with a mark (or in a few spots we'll recognize nations by shading). The two nations are accepted to contrast just regarding the creation innovation.
Two Goods
Two products are delivered by the two nations. We expect a trade economy. This implies there is no cash used to make exchanges. Rather, for exchange to happen, merchandise must be exchanged for different products. Consequently we require no less than two merchandise in the model. Let the two delivered products be wine and cheddar.
One Factor of Production
Work is the one factor of creation used to deliver every one of the merchandise. The factor is homogeneous and can uninhibitedly move between enterprises.
Utility Maximization/Demand
In Ricardo's unique introduction of the model he concentrated solely on the supply side. Just later did John Stuart Mill bring request into the model. Since much can be educated with Ricardo's deficient model we continue at first without formally determining interest or utility capacities. Later we will utilize the total utility particular characterized underneath to delineate a harmony in the model.
At the point when required we will expect that total utility can be spoken to by a component of the shape U = CCCW where CC and CW are the total amounts of cheddar and wine devoured in the nation. This capacity is picked in light of the fact that it has properties that make it simple to delineate a balance. The most imperative component is that the capacity is homothetic. This suggests the nation expends wine and cheddar in the same settled extent, at given costs, paying little respect to salary. On the off chance that two nations share the same homothetic inclinations, at that point when the nations share similar costs, as they will in unhindered commerce, they will likewise expend wine and cheddar in a similar extent.
General Equilibrium
The Ricardian demonstrate is a general harmony display. This implies it depicts a total roundabout stream of cash in return for products and enterprises. Along these lines, the offer of merchandise and enterprises creates income to the organizations which thusly is utilized to pay for the factor administrations (wages to laborers for this situation) utilized as a part of generation. The factor wage (compensation) is utilized, thus, to purchase the products and enterprises delivered by the organizations. This produces income to the organizations and the cycle rehashes. A "general balance" emerges when costs of products, administrations and elements are, for example, to even out free market activity in all business sectors at the same time.
Production
The creation capacities beneath speak to industry generation, not firm creation. The business comprises of numerous little firms in light of the suspicion of impeccable rivalry.
Production of Cheese
US:Qc=Lc(hrs)/aLC(hrs/lb)
France :Q*c=L*c/aLC*
where
Q C = amount of cheddar created in the US.
L C = measure of work connected to cheddar generation in the US.
a LC = unit-work necessity in cheddar creation in the US. ( long stretches of work important to create one unit of cheddar) what's more, where every single featured variable are characterized similarly yet allude to the procedure in France.
Production of Wine
US:Qw=Lw/aLW
France :Q*w=L*w/a*LW
where Q W = amount of wine delivered in the US.
L W = measure of work connected to wine creation in the US.
a LW = unit-work prerequisite in wine creation in the US. ( long periods of work important to deliver one unit of wine)
what's more, where every single featured variable are characterized similarly however allude to the procedure in France.
The unit-work prerequisites characterize the innovation of creation in two nations. Contrasts in these work costs crosswise over nations speak to contrasts in innovation.
Asset Constraint
The asset imperative in this model is likewise a work limitation since work is the main factor of generation.
US :Lc+Lw=L
France :Lc*+Lw*=L*
where L is the work blessing in the US. That is, the aggregate number of hours the work drive will give. Again all featured factors allude to France. At the point when the asset requirement holds with uniformity it infers that the asset is completely utilized. A more broad determination of the model would require just that the total of work connected in the two ventures be not exactly or equivalent to the work enrichment. In any case, the suppositions of the model will ensure that generation utilizes every single accessible asset, thus we can utilize the less broad particular above.
Factor Mobility
The one factor of generation, work, is thought to be fixed crosswise over nations. In this manner work can't move starting with one nation then onto the next looking for higher wages. In any case, work is thought to be unreservedly and costlessly versatile between businesses inside a nation. This implies specialists working in the one business can be moved to the next business with no cost brought about by the organizations or the laborers.
Transportation Costs
The model accept that merchandise can be transported between nations at no cost. This presumption disentangles the composition of the model. On the off chance that vehicle costs were incorporated, it can be demonstrated that the key consequences of the model may even now acquire.
Exogenous and Endogenous Variables
In depicting any model it is constantly valuable to monitor which factors are exogenous and which are endogenous. Exogenous factors are those factors in a model that are dictated by forms that are not portrayed inside the model itself. When depicting and settling a model, exogenous factors are taken as settled parameters whose qualities are known. They are factors over which the operators inside the model have no control.
In the Ricardian display the parameters ( L, a LC, aLW ) are exogenous. The comparing featured factors are exogenous in the other nation. Endogenous factors are those factors decided when the model is fathomed. In this way finding the answer for a model means fathoming for the estimations of the endogenous factors. Operators in the model can control or impact the endogenous factors through their activities. In the Ricardian show the factors ( L C, L W, QC , QW ) are endogenous. In like manner the comparing featured factors are endogenous in the other nation.
Related Questions
drjack9650@gmail.com
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.