DQ # 1 1-a) Is free trade fair? Why or why not? Discuss! 1-b) What’s the differe
ID: 1138685 • Letter: D
Question
DQ # 1
1-a) Is free trade fair? Why or why not? Discuss!
1-b) What’s the difference between Heckscher and Ohlin & new trade theory ? Which one has more implications to current international trade patterns?
DQ # 2
Unions in developed nations often oppose imports from low-wage countries and advocate trade barriers to protect jobs from what they often characterize as “unfair” import competition. Is such competition “unfair?” Do you think that this argument is in the best interests of (a) the unions, (b) the people they represent, and/or (c) the country as a whole?
DQ # 3 Based on Case Concept
In the last few decades, the auto industry has shifted from one in which a few, large companies primarily manufactured in their domestic markets and sold in their domestic markets, to one in which a few large companies serve the world market, manufacturing around the globe to capture competitive advantages wherever they can.
3-a) Why do companies like Toyota and Nissan have large operations in the U.S. market? Why don’t American companies have a large presence in Japan?
3-b) Why BMW and Mercedes have established manufacturing operations in the U.S. market, while American companies are shifting their production to places like Mexico. Similarly, reflect on the new agreement between Toyota and Mazda whereby Mazda will produce cars at its plant in Mexico for Toyota to sell in the United States.
3-c) Use the applicable theories presented in the chapter to explain the current changes in the car industry, and in the future. Volkswagen, for example, has just committed to opening a new factory in Tennessee where wage rates are relatively low. Discuss!
Explanation / Answer
D-Q-1
1-A
Free trade means there are no trade barriers between the nations that involve in free trade, but these nations has different level of economic growth & development, regulatory framework and infrastructure. It means that there is a scope of exploitation, cases of economic rent, infighting and issues related to briber and unethical practices. These concerns grow when free trade takes place and overseas enterprises try to use it in their favor. It makes free trade by no means to be fair as one country can prevent malpractices due to robust regulatory system, but another participant country can suffer due to the lack of regulations and poor means to fight against these malpractices. It makes free trade to be unfair as the only objective of the free trade, is to use the market of each other and grow in their own country even if it comes at a cost of another economy. Besides, free trade also works in a scope to prevent trade relations with other nations, outside the area of free trade agreement. It puts additional burden upon the country that could get the better deal if free trade was not in place. Hence, it also adds to the unfairness due to free trade.
1-B
H-O model (Heckscher-Ohlin) proposes that all firms are same in all the countries, but new trade theory says that firms are heterogeneous in nature. H-O model has identified that each country has the same production function and each country can have the same production technology to do so that is contradicted by the new trade theory that says that each country has different competitive advantage and capabilities. Besides, H-O model does not focus neither on employment nor on firms working in different countries, but firm’s behavior is strongly discussed by the new trade theory.
New trade theory has more implications in the current international trade pattern. As per the existing international trade patterns, one firm can operate in more than one country and produce different goods while opting for the global sourcing. This gives huge importance to the diversity of the firm and firm’s behavior. In the same tune, new trade theory gives more importance to the firms and their objectives while pursuing the international trade of different nature. Further, network effects and increasing return to scale are proposed by the new trade theory that gets more attention and significance in existing international trade scenario.
Pl. repost other unanswered questions for their proper answers!
Related Questions
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.