Why did the smaller states object to the Virginia Plan? Roger Sherman and other
ID: 1136215 • Letter: W
Question
Why did the smaller states object to the Virginia Plan?
Roger Sherman and other small state delegates disliked Madison and Randolph and did not want them to receive recognition for advancing the Virginia Plan.
In accordance with the institutions principle, small states wanted to maintain the existing institutions (the Articles of Confederation), but the institutions principle does not apply to large states.
The Virginia Plan provided greater representation in the national legislature for larger and/or wealthier states, which disadvantaged the small states.
The small states tended to be from the North and objected to the strong proslavery content in the Virginia Plan.
The smaller states feared that the national government would force them to pay equal shares of the national budget.
A.Roger Sherman and other small state delegates disliked Madison and Randolph and did not want them to receive recognition for advancing the Virginia Plan.
B.In accordance with the institutions principle, small states wanted to maintain the existing institutions (the Articles of Confederation), but the institutions principle does not apply to large states.
C.The Virginia Plan provided greater representation in the national legislature for larger and/or wealthier states, which disadvantaged the small states.
D.The small states tended to be from the North and objected to the strong proslavery content in the Virginia Plan.
E.The smaller states feared that the national government would force them to pay equal shares of the national budget.
Explanation / Answer
answer: c) Virginia plan defined a good representation of larger states in the two houses of the legislature. This representation was done on the basis of the population size in the proportion of the seats or the representation granted. In such a scenario, the smaller states would be granted little representation and as a result of which, their decision would be kept unnoticed. This was the reason why the smaller states objected for the acceptance of Virginia plan and went with the New Jersey plan which said one state one vote negligible of the population size.
Related Questions
drjack9650@gmail.com
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.