..il AT&T; 1:58 PM @ 18%-+ utsa.blackboard.com 13 of 13 90 Taking Sides Clashing
ID: 1108760 • Letter: #
Question
..il AT&T; 1:58 PM @ 18%-+ utsa.blackboard.com 13 of 13 90 Taking Sides Clashing Views on Envionmental sues, Exade EXPLORING THE ISSUE Should Agricultural Animal Wastes Be Exempt from the Requirements of Superfund Legislation? Critical Thinking and Reflection 1. In the pant many industrial chemical wtes were disposed of accoeding to the test peactice" of the time (as defined by laws and regulations). Later it was realined that "best practice was not very good Should compa nies be held liable for public health effects in sach cases? 2. ln the past many industrial chemical wastes wene disposed of in the cheapest possible way, without regand to potential publk health effects, Should companies be beld liable for public health effects in such cas? 3·Sbould the way the putlic 4and regulators) regards emissions of toxic chemicals depend on the sale of the operation responsible sor the emissions (compare the old-fashioned family farm with factory farms? Should the impact of potential regulations on the protitalbility of regulated baninesses be a factor in deciding Is There Common Ground? The thetoeic of American political debate of very traditional themes. An interesting point hidden in the readings is the ques- tion of scalle Walter Bradley speaks of dairy operations as if they were all traditional lailly farms. Ed Hopkins stresses that a great many modern dairy and pig and chicken) fanms are much, much bigger than that and the chemical emissions they generate are much, mach larger than anything produced by a failly farm. Both agree that theee is a need to contsol pollution, but Walter Bradley thinks existing laws ane entisely adequate for the rewww.mhhe.cocraecntra ld Hopkins argues that we need the reporting provisions of the Supertund regulations to determine just how bad Additional Resources the peoblem s Among them ane familly values and the depend ence of America's strength and identity on the lamily farmer Examine news eports for a week ee how often these you notice other hetorical themes as well Create Central Sheila Kaplan and Marilyn B Snell, "Sapping the 1. Is it reasonable to say that a substance is a toxic waste of geeat concem when peoduced in large amounts, but not when produced in small amounts? Where should one draw the line Superfund's Strength," Nation(May 3, 2010 Sthen Lester and Anne RabG, Spefond tE of the Storm (Center for Health Environment & between "small and "largeT 2. Are there other ways besides the reporting requirements of the Emerpency Planning and Community Right-to-know Act CRA) to onna Rummel-Bobka, "The Rasel Convention: A Global Approach for the Management of Hazand ous Wastes, mental Poliky and Law(vol 24 o.1, 1994 Internet References. .. & Justice (CHEDExplanation / Answer
The agricultural animal waste should be exempt because that would keep the EPA from including animal manure as a hazardous waste. This bill has been introduced in U.S., it would exempt pollutary litter and manure from the requirements of superfund law. This bill also eliminates the reporting requirements for livestock and poultry producers about manure emissions under the Superfund law.
This is being done because some farms are very big and the chemical emission from these farms is very high,therefore, there is a need to control the pollution. There should be a limit on the chemical emmission from the farms, so that, they do not cause environmental pollution.
Related Questions
Navigate
Integrity-first tutoring: explanations and feedback only — we do not complete graded work. Learn more.